Healthy in the Wrong Way: When Food Marketers Don’t Listen

Making use of facts on food items-assert frequency gathered by Mintel Company, we discovered that “clean” promises – labels that strain almost nothing synthetic has been added – are the speediest-expanding category in both France and the US.  ­­

“Enriched” promises are the the very least utilized, though “diet” claims grew likewise in equally nations around the world. “Whole” statements like “wholesome” or “organic” grew a lot quicker in France and are now the next most well known classification, while they remained in third put in the US.

French match, US mismatch

We then took a nearer glance at how this contrasts with customer choices in every region. Though prior study has centered on company behaviour or buyer response, it is scarce to have both of those in the same study. 

We gathered and evaluated info on consumer preferences for these 4 types of statements from two samples of French and American buyers matched on age, gender, revenue and education and learning levels. 

Our findings suggest that People like promises about the presence of good than about the absence of undesirable, as illustrated in the top rated still left chart.

French buyers, nevertheless, like nature-based mostly claims that the product or service is healthful due to the fact its all-natural houses have been preserved. This getting is presented in the base left chart in which we see the eco-friendly line (indicating tastes for character-based statements) is higher than the yellow line (diet-centered promises).

These marked shopper preferences should really make it effortless for marketers to give people today what they want. We located this was the scenario in France where promises that people like most are also extra commonly used on cereal packaging. As a outcome, the base appropriate chart, showing claim frequency, closely matches the base still left chart.

Having said that, points are completely different in the US, exactly where there is a huge mismatch in between the statements that people like and the promises that companies are utilizing. The the very least-well-liked statements, all those about “diet”, are very frequently utilized, though the most popular statements about products and solutions staying “enriched” are substantially fewer regular.

Why the US received it wrong

To have an understanding of why there is this mismatch, we pooled information on corporation ownership. Our findings suggest that community companies make less health and fitness statements on their packaging than personal firms in each nations around the world and yet have the maximum matching fees. This suggests that companies can correctly match customer anticipations with out earning several wellbeing promises if they are the suitable types.

Whilst significant cereal companies like Kellogg’s and Typical Mills market their merchandise in the way American customers desire, we located that scaled-down, privately-owned corporations are more very likely to use “diet” statements that people like much less. In distinction, French privately-owned organizations make the exact variety of statements that community firms make.

We explored numerous hypotheses as to why personal companies are not marketing their merchandise to satisfy consumers’ expectations. The 1 that we assume is plausible is that these lesser American providers are driven by a mission to enhance the wellness of buyers, rather of just producing wellbeing claims that customers like. These corporations are in simple fact carrying out what is healthier, which is to take away salt, sugar and other additives.

We arrived to this conclusion by analysing the names of the privately-owned organizations. We observed a greater proportion of all those that have company names referencing diet or overall health, these kinds of as “Low Karb”. This could make clear why these providers really don’t give persons what they want – they are focused on supplying folks what they must try to eat, which is far more healthy foodstuff. 

It is intriguing to see that not all companies are buyer-oriented in the way we presume them to be. They do not essentially aim on what the industry desires. This could be due to the fact they are pursuing a niche method the place they only go right after tiny subsegments of persons who seriously want to get rid of bodyweight.

Alternatively, it could be due to the fact they want to be the “good guys” and are likely above and over and above what individuals want. What we are looking at in the US data indicates that some lesser companies have an understanding of they have a responsibility to give additional wholesome solutions.

Redefining ‘healthy’ and other summary phrases

It is difficult for providers when shoppers are captivated to buzzwords like “natural”, “fresh” or “organic”, as these promises are not scientifically controlled and have no affiliation with the dietary excellent of the food items. Food entrepreneurs have to have to recognize how consumers are decoding wholesome foodstuff, and preserve observe of how these thoughts adjust, even when they do not align with nourishment.

These conceptual, catch-all phrases lengthen further than the foodstuff business. Just about just about every corporation desires their item to be “cool” or “high quality”. Having said that, these text can be interpreted in a lot of unique techniques. It is therefore critical to unpack what men and women mean when they use these informal conditions. Usually, we feel we recognize each and every other, but we are speaking about vastly distinct items. 


Pierre Chandon is the L’Oréal Chaired Professor of Promoting – Innovation and Creative imagination at INSEAD and the Director of the INSEAD-Sorbonne Université Behavioural Lab. Enjoy his TEDxINSEAD talk on Epicurean nudges.

Romain Cadario is an Assistant Professor at the Rotterdam College of Administration, Erasmus University.

INSEAD Expertise is now on LinkedIn. Be part of the dialogue currently.

Observe INSEAD Information on Twitter and Facebook.